Wednesday, 9 June 2010

New Zealand and U.S spearhead opposition to loss and damage provisions in negotiating text





By Makereta Komai of Climate Pasifika in Bonn, Germany

07 June 2010, Bonn, Germany --- New Zealand has joined the United States in opposing a proposal from many countries including the Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) for the establishment of an international mechanism to address loss and damage under the United Nations climate change convention.

Also supported by Norway and Canada, our Pacific neighbour reiterates its position that it’s difficult to prove the link between climate change and any specific extreme event.

But recognising the importance of the issue to AOSIS, Norway said it’s open to discussing them, according to the Earth Negotiations Bulletin (ENB).

ENB follows the negotiations daily and publishes a four page summary for delegates, NGO’s and the media.

The United States, while acknowledging that all countries face adaptation challenges said an insurance mechanism is not appropriate to address loss and damage.

The U.S however, gave a proviso, saying ‘it would be willing to discuss a suite of risk management procedures and mechanisms to address loss and damage.’

This position runs contrary to the AOSIS position, said a Pacific Island delegate attending the negotiations here in Bonn.

Australia, on the other hand, reiterated its position saying that any institutional arrangement on adaptation must focus on co-operation, shared information, trend and gap analyses, technical advice and capacity building.

Bangladesh speaking on behalf of least developed countries (LDC) and supported by Cook Islands urged Parties to consider the establishment of an institutional structure to facilitate the implementation of adaptation actions.

AOSIS, which groups all islands in the Pacific, Caribbean and Indian Ocean, is lobbying for an adaptation body under the Convention with a new funding window, similar to the Adaptation Fund under the Kyoto Protocol.

While Pacific countries are fighting for recognition of their special vulnerabilities as a result of climate change, countries that belong to the Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) are also lamenting their economic loss from the erosion of fossil fuel.

“Fossil fuel will be one of the victims of climate change and we should be included in any response measure in the Convention or any new agreement, said Saudi Arabia.

“Our countries should also be compensated for our loss.”

But Barbados supported by Grenada argued that ‘patients suffering from a common cold should receive a different kind of attention than those with a serious illness” implying that the needs of AOSIS are more urgent than those of other regions.

Outgoing UN climate change chief, Yvo de Boer agreed that the demands of OPEC countries are also legitimate.

“Their interests are just as legitimate. They are afraid that aggressive action on climate change is going to decrease the amount of oil they are producing and hurt them economically, said de Boer.

At the same time, the small island countries are saying if there is too little action on the part of industrialised nations and emerging developed countries, it will result in near extinction of some island countries.

“That will mean low level of ambition, which translates into the extinction of some island countries, de Boer added.

Indigenous People’s launch global network on climate change


By Makereta Komai for Climate Pasifika in Bonn, Germany
09 June 2010, Bonn, Germany --- An indigenous people’s network on climate change was launched in Bonn Tuesday, to coincide with the global climate change negotiations now into its second week.

Calling itself the Indigenous Peoples Global Network on Climate Change and Self Determination (IPCCSD), the new group hopes to push for the inclusion of the rights of indigenous peoples into any climate change deal.



“We want to contribute to finding solutions to climate change. We believe we can use our traditional knowledge to adapt and mitigate against the impacts of climate change, said Joseph Ole Simel, representing indigenous peoples in Kenya.

An issue of interest to indigenous peoples in the current negotiations is the reduction of emissions through deforestation and degradation (REDD).

“We are happy with the current language in the AWG-LCA text. The text recognises the need to respect the rights of indigenous peoples and allows for their full participation in any REDD activities, said Victoria Tauli-Corpuz, the interim chair of the new indigenous peoples group.

The new group will ensure the views and experiences of indigenous peoples on climate change impacts and solutions are made visible at the regional and global arenas.

The group represents seven regions of the globe, including the Pacific.

There is no membership from the Pacific yet and the secretariat, which is based in the Philippines, is urging indigenous people’s groups in the Pacific to join the global network.

Ms Makereta Komai will be covering the Bonn Climate Change negotiations from 31 May – 11 June 2010, thanks to support from Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme (SPREP) and the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF). She will provide daily coverage of the negotiations via PACNEWS and the SPREP website www.sprep.org, the climate pasifika blogspot, http://climatepasifika.blogspot.com and the PINA Green page http://green.pina.com.fj/

Mexico won’t raise expectations for a legally binding agreement in Cancun, Ambassador de Alba



By Makereta Komai for Climate Pasifika in Bonn, Germany

08 June 2010, Bonn, Germany --- Mexico says it won’t raise expectations for a legally binding climate change agreement at the end of the year in Cancun but will await the outcomes of the current negotiations to see what practical conclusions can be reached.

 “Be prepared, not everything will be solved in Cancun, said Mexico’s climate change top diplomat, Ambassador Luis Alfonso de Alba while briefing international media here Tuesday.

There are three options for a final outcome in Cancun, said the Mexican Ambassador, who is meeting informally with all negotiating groups in preparation for the Conference of the Parties (COP) in December.

“I can tell you that we may not have a single treaty in Cancun.  One option is to have Treaties or Protocols.  The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change Convention allows for two or three protocols. There is the Kyoto Protocol and we can have an additional instrument that complement it, said Ambassador de Alba.

The other is to have a single treaty that will replace the Kyoto Protocol or have a combination of Treaties and Decisions by the Conference of the Parties.

Ambassador de Alba said Cancun doesn’t want a repeat of Copenhagen.

“We probably aimed too high in Copenhagen. It was evident that we could not achieve an agreement because we arrived with a set of documents that was not sufficiently mature to lead to an agreement.

“The final text was negotiated late in the process in Copenhagen. We want to change that in Mexico.



 
“We are not going to aim for a deal at the last minute by involving heads of states. That is why we are negotiating here before the ministerial session.’’

He said the media should refrain from describing the Mexico COP 16 meeting as a summit.

“It’s not a meeting that we should expect the attendance of high number of heads of state and leaders, which is in line with the level of the Conference of the Parties. Copenhagen was the first that was attended by a large number of world leaders.

Ambassador de Alba said the current round of negotiations underway in Bonn, and two more scheduled in August and October would be good indicators of what can be achieved in Cancun.
“We are trying to identify issues in each of the negotiating chapters and see how much progress can be made here on the critical issues of adaptation, mitigation, technology, finance, forests. REDD. We are obviously following the two track process under the Bali Roadmap.

To push the process forward, Mexico has had informal meetings with negotiating groups, including the Alliance of Small Islands States (AOSIS).

In his briefing, Ambassador de Alba reiterated his government’s preferred position that a legally binding agreement be reached in Cancun, but details need to be worked out including the definition of ‘legally binding’ and what specific items need to be legally binding.

AOSIS in response suggested that legal form was a 'crunch issue' that should be addressed formally in an open and transparent manner as soon as possible and not wait until August session.

“This is to avoid waiting to address this issue at the last minute in Cancun should Parties need time to convert potential decisions into a legal instrument, said an AOSIS briefing paper.

Ambassador de Alba said there have been a number of informal sessions in Mexico wit Parties and the two chairs of the ad hoc working groups to try and advance discussions on financing and other substantive issues. We’ve also visited a number of countries in different continents and attended a number of important multilateral meetings to discuss our expectations. 



“This strategy involves different levels of decision making process. We started with the consultations on the level of negotiators and we will now report to the ministerial meeting, as a follow up to the decisions reached here.

In Mexico, President Felipe Calderon has taken the lead in the preparations for COP16 meeting.

“He is personally engaged in meetings at his level and is video conferencing with other world leaders to keep up the momentum on climate change, said Ambassador de Alba.

Mexico will host the UNFCCC Conference of the Parties from 29 November – 10 December.

Ms Makereta Komai will be covering the Bonn Climate Change negotiations from 31 May – 11 June 2010, thanks to support from Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme (SPREP) and the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF). She will provide daily coverage of the negotiations via PACNEWS and the SPREP website www.sprep.org, the climate pasifika blogspot, http://climatepasifika.blogspot.com and the PINA Green page http://green.pina.com.fj/



“Too many meetings’ shifted outside UNFCCC process, civil societies concerned




By Makereta Komai for Climate Pasifika in Bonn, Germany

08 June 2010, Bonn, Germany --- Concerns have been raised by international civil society organisations following the climate change negotiations in Bonn that ‘too many’ meetings are being convened outside the United Nations climate change convention process in preparation for Cancun in December.

“Negotiations on forests have been moved to Paris-Oslo on REDD process and the sources of finance are being addressed by the UN Secretary General’s high level advisory group, said the NGO’s briefing paper.



The NGO’s claim was strongly refuted by Mexico’s climate change diplomat, Ambassador Luis Alfonso Alba.

“I don’t share those concerns. Having these meetings are not new. It is something that we do every day at the United Nations and even in our national parliaments.

“Small groups are absolutely necessary in negotiations to build understanding. What is more important is that no decisions are taken in these small groups, said Ambassador de Alba.

Mexico has been holding small informal group discussions to bring about greater clarity on difficult issues before they are taken to the plenary sessions.

“We invite all like minded Parties to the table but the views of other Parties are also well represented in these small groups. We do not have a summary of the discussions because these meetings are only for the benefit of the chairs.

“There is nothing new or sinister about these informal sessions, said Ambassador de Alba.

Eight international NGO’s came out with their assessment of the Bonn talks Tuesday painting a ‘gloomy’ picture of the expected outcome here if the United States continues what it calls a ‘new paradigm for climate diplomacy.’

“The climate negotiations are being led astray. We lost our way in Copenhagen. We urgently need to get back to the Bali Roadmap here in Bonn, said the NGOs briefing paper.

Instead of honouring the Bali Action Plan, the US and a number of developed nations intend to ‘sink’ the Kyoto Protocol and ‘jump ship’ to a much leakier vessel created under the ad hoc working group on long term co-operative action (AWG-LCA).

“Rather than honour the Bali plan, they are now seeking to migrate favoured elements of the Kyoto Protocol (e.g. markets) into a new agreement under the AWG-LCA and to establish a system of voluntary pledges.”

The Bonn assessment report was compiled by Action Aid, Friends of the Earth, International Forum on Globalisation, Jubilee South, Pan African Climate Justice Alliance, Third World Network, Tebtebba and Sustainable Energy and Economy Network.

Ms Komai will be covering the Bonn Climate Change negotiations from 31 May – 11 June 2010, thanks to support from Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme (SPREP) and the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF). She will provide daily coverage of the negotiations via PACNEWS and the SPREP website www.sprep.org, the climate pasifika blogspot, http://climatepasifika.blogspot.com and the PINA Green page http://green.pina.com.fj/

PNG proposes a ministerial meeting to provide political guidance before Cancun



By Makereta Komai for Climate Pasifika in Bonn, Germany

07 June 2010, Bonn, Germany – A proposal to convene a ministerial meeting outside the United Nations climate change body’s scheduled sessions has been proposed by Papua New Guinea, in the lead up to the Conference of the Parties (COP) meeting in Mexico in December this year.

The proposal drew mixed reactions from State Parties at the climate change negotiations in Bonn this week.
PNG said the ministerial session would review the outcomes of three scheduled negotiations in June, August and October before any final conclusions are presented at the COP session in Cancun.



“This is an attempt to avoid the failure of Copenhagen last year. The ministers did not have time to meet and review the negotiating text, said PNG.

“The meeting should not run parallel to the negotiations but feed into providing advice and political guidance on crunch issues to allow negotiators to do the final touches to the final resolutions before Cancun.

Recognising time and financial constraints, PNG suggested limited participation with regional and negotiating groupings represented.

“Transparency and inclusiveness are important, thus the meeting should be open ended, said the PNG proposal.

There are two scheduled one weeklong negotiations planned for August and October this year.

The pre-COP ministerial meeting is proposed to be convened between October and December.

Spain and the European Union favoured the idea of getting political guidance before COP16 in Mexico.

Brazil expressed caution about holding another ministerial meeting before Cancun, as technical negotiations need to have enough time to clean up the negotiating text.



“The proposal is difficult especially if Parties wanted to keep the process open and inclusive until Cancun, said Brazil.

Singapore and Venezuela did not favour the idea saying negotiators already have a tight work schedule and there are no funds to hold smaller meetings.

PNG’s proposal will be discussed further before Parties decide whether it should be reflected in the draft conclusions of the Subsidiary Body for Implementation (SBI) contact group.

Ms Komai will be covering the Bonn Climate Change negotiations from 31 May – 11 June 2010, thanks to support from Secretariat of the Pacific Regional Environment Programme (SPREP) and the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF). She will provide daily coverage of the negotiations via PACNEWS and the SPREP website www.sprep.org, the climate pasifika blogspot, http://climatepasifika.blogspot.com and the PINA Green page http://green.pina.com.fj/